Face-to-face appeal of the exam. Appeal of the USE about disagreement with the points given: the procedure and deadlines for filing

Each region independently sets the deadlines for informing USE participants about the results of the exam. Traditionally, this is 1-2 days after the announcement by Rosobrnadzor of the minimum number of points in the subject.

Schools (for graduates of the current year), as well as PES or education authorities (depending on the organizational and territorial scheme adopted in the region) of the region are required to post lists of USE participants with exam results on information stands and / or their own websites. The appearance of the lists on the information stand is considered the moment of the official announcement of the results of the exam.

If the announcement of results is delayed by more than 2 days, the local education authority should be contacted.

1. When can an appeal be filed?

The USE participant has the right to appeal:

about violation of the established procedure for conducting the exam - on the day of the exam after passing the exam forms before leaving the PES

on disagreement with the USE results - within 2 WORKING days after the official announcement of the exam results and familiarization of the USE participant with them

Appeals will not be accepted:

in connection with the violation by the USE participant of the rules of conduct on the USE or the rules for filling out forms

2. Appeal about violation of the established procedure for conducting the exam

Actions of the USE participant:

at the end of the exam, without leaving the PES, receive from the organizer in the audience a form (two copies), according to which the appeal is drawn up

transfer both copies to an authorized representative of the SEC, who is obliged to accept and certify them with his signature, give one copy to the USE participant, transfer the other to the conflict commission

receive the result of the consideration of the appeal in your educational institution or in local governments exercising powers in the field of education (MOE) no later than 3 calendar days after its submission

• If the appeal is satisfied, the USE result is canceled and the participant is given the opportunity to take the USE in this subject on another (reserve) day. He is assigned the date and place of re-taking the exam in the relevant subject.

  Notes:
  The decision to cancel the results of the exam can be made:

• if an internal investigation of the SEC confirms the fact of violation of the established procedure for conducting the exam
• if the conflict commission satisfied the appeal of violation of the established procedure for conducting the exam
• if an authorized representative of the SEC, a public observer or authorized representatives of Rosobrnadzor, as well as prosecutors and law enforcement agencies, establish violations of the USE procedure at the USE venue, which could have a significant impact on the results of the USE

  3. Appeal of disagreement with the results of the exam

  Actions of the USE participant:

• within 2 working days after I officially got acquainted with the results, receive from the responsible secretary of the conflict commission (for graduates of the current year - from the head of their educational institution) a form in 2 copies, according to which the appeal is drawn up (it is possible to draw up an appeal in any form)
• draw up an appeal in 2 copies
• transfer both copies to the above persons (who are required to accept and certify them with their signature, give one copy to the USE participant, and transfer the other to the conflict commission)
• receive information about the time and place of the appeal
• if possible, come to the procedure for considering appeals to the conflict commission, having a passport and a pass with the stamp "Unified State Examination forms handed over" (or a PPE stamp)
• confirm in the minutes of the appeal that he was shown copies of his forms and the correctness of recognition of his answers in the forms
• participate in an appeal
• sign the minutes of the appeal

  Possible solutions to the conflict commission:

• rejection of the appeal due to the absence of technical errors in the processing of the USE forms and errors in assessing answers to tasks in free form by experts and saving the points set;
• satisfaction of the appeal and the issuance of other points.

  Notes

• When considering an appeal, instead of the USE participant or together with him, his parents (legal representatives) may be present, who must also have passports with them (the legal representative must also have other documents confirming his authority).
• If the USE participant or his parent (legal representative) did not appear for the consideration of the appeal, the correctness of the recognition of the answer forms is confirmed by the members of the conflict commission.

Drafts as materials of the appeal are not considered.

Attention! Based on the results of the consideration of the appeal, the number of points awarded can be changed both upwards and downwards!

According to the press service of Rosobrnadzor.

How to appeal the exam? This question was asked more than once by each applicant, since sometimes even one point can decide the fate of a budget place. How to properly defend your position? How long can this be done and what part of the work can be complained about?

Appeal to the exam: the structure of the work, the appealed parts

So, before you start thinking about getting additional points, you need to study in detail the structure of the examination paper. The exam itself consists, as a rule, of three sections: the first two are test tasks (choosing one correct answer and answers from a sequence of numbers / phrases), the third is the written part. The USE score is summed up taking into account all three chapters of the work - this is the so-called primary score, which is then translated using a complex formula into a secondary one in a hundred-point system. It should be noted right away that an appeal can be filed only for the written part of the work, that is, for tasks related to the detailed answer of the graduate. How to do it right? Now we will analyze in detail all the possible nuances.

How to appeal the exam: an algorithm of actions

So, the appeal can be filed within two days from the date of the official announcement of the results. So there is no need to rush into this. As a rule, each classroom should inform the graduates about the point of filing a complaint and the time. If this has not been done, then after the completion of the examination work, you need to approach the chief expert of the exam site and clarify these data. It is also worth asking teachers in advance how this kind of application is submitted. In general, you need to go to such a commission with a teacher or with a tutor.

How to appeal the exam? Complaints of this kind are very often filed for the third part of the obligatory Russian language exam, since unaccounted examples or incorrectly defined problems are very common in the essay. That is why, immediately after submitting the work, you need to sketch out an approximate text of the work on a sheet and take it to the teacher or tutor, who must analyze this essay and, after the results are announced, say whether there is a chance to increase your score or not. The same applies to work in other subjects. You need to sketch your answers or decisions in order to be prepared in the commission and be able to answer any question and defend your point of view, since the experts sitting there are not always friendly. Now you know how to appeal the exam and what you need to do.

Causes a lot of criticism lately: these are scandals with the placement of answer options on the network, and the unworthy level of the work itself. How to deal with this, if every year there are more and more questions? The Ministry of Education is probably doing everything possible to equalize the chances of the applicants. It is for this that you need to strictly know how to appeal the exam and what is needed in order to get additional points, which, perhaps, will decide the difficult fate of the applicant.

Many graduates will breathe a sigh of relief after graduation, leaving behind a difficult and nervous period of preparation, extra classes, worries and worries about how the test will pass. It remains to wait for the results and hope for the best with. However, there is another category of schoolchildren - guys who do not agree with the assessment for the Unified State Examination and believe that they actually earned more points, and the mark given by the members of the commission does not reflect their real level of knowledge.

Graduates who wish to challenge the result of the exam can resort to an appeal - a procedure aimed at protecting the rights of examinees. Whether or not to file an appeal is a personal matter for everyone. On the one hand, this is additional stress. But sometimes two or three points can be decisive when entering a dream university or enrolling in a budget place, so that the student is ready to fight to the end, challenging the points given.

Of course, a competent appeal to the commission is not just a scandal about the fact that you were unfairly assessed. In order for everything to be successful, you need not only to be sure that your answers are correct, but also to be able to communicate with the members of the commission, file an application on time and correctly, and also clearly understand which aspects of the work can be challenged. Let's find out all the nuances of this process, so that if necessary you are fully equipped!

If you do not consider fair the results of the exam, they can be challenged!

When can an appeal be filed?

At a time when the Unified State Examination was only part of the all-Russian practice, it was believed that such an appeal was a disastrous business. The commission was reluctant to issue works for review, and outsiders, including even the parents of schoolchildren, were not allowed to attend the procedure. Moreover, the students were scared that the commission could only revise the results of the Unified State Examination in the direction of lowering the scores, and not all graduates were ready to take such a risk.

To date, the appeal is not considered such a difficult matter. The main thing at the same time is to understand what exactly you disagree with and how to proceed further. In the Russian practice of passing the exam, there are two options for appeals:

• challenging the examination procedure itself, the violation of which led to the fact that you could not write the exam as successfully as possible. For example, such a case is considered to be a shortage of draft forms for students. The appeal must be filed immediately at the end of the exam and, as practice shows, it is satisfied;
• challenging the points received for the exam - such appeals most often affect subjects of a humanitarian nature. Many students dispute the results of the essay on,. The exact subjects are rarely disputed. This appeal must be filed after the announcement of the results of the exam. You need to write a statement within two days after the result is brought to your knowledge.

An appeal is written to the conflict commission - a special structure that was created to protect the rights of students. It is worth remembering that the powers of this body do not include such matters as:

• a score for solving short answer tasks - there is nothing to interpret in this part of the KIMs, so the written word, combination of words or number is simply evaluated on the fact of their correctness;
• violations that were committed by the student himself. Disputing the fact that you were sent out the door because of conversations with a neighbor or cheating will definitely not work;
• lost points due to the fact that the student incorrectly completed the work, mixed up the lines of entering answers in the examination form, and the like. The inattention of the student remains only on his conscience;
• assessment of draft forms. Even if you wrote an excellent essay, but did not have time to rewrite it in the answer sheet, it is useless to demand that this sheet be checked. At the exam, they immediately warn that the draft exists only for the personal convenience of the examinee, but is not checked by the members of the commission.

When and how does an appeal take place?

The schedule for the exam, as well as the deadlines for filing appeals and their consideration, Rosobrnadzor will publish by mid-January. Based on the practice of past years, we can say that usually an appeal is scheduled 2-3 days after the receipt of applications (but no later than on the 4th business day). For example, if the results of the exam were announced on June 14, then no later than June 15-16, you will need to apply for an appeal, and the procedure itself will be scheduled for the 17-20th.

As mentioned above, this application must be submitted immediately on the day of the exam - before the student leaves the exam class. You need to write an application in two copies - the first of them goes to the conflict commission, and the second remains with the student. The graduate must ensure that a member of the examination committee puts a note on the application that the document has been accepted for consideration. The appeal procedure is carried out with the obligatory presence of certain persons, including:

• organizers who were not part of the observers at the exam;
• specialists responsible for the technical part (for example, video surveillance in the classroom);
• public observers;
• security officers;
• health workers.

The application must be registered in a special journal and considered within two days after submission. The date, place and time of the procedure must be communicated to the student and his parents or legal guardians.

As a result, the commission may satisfy the requirements of the student, or, on the contrary, decide that they have no reason to satisfy. A positive decision of the commission means that the result of the work will be canceled, and the student will be able to rewrite the exam - special days are allocated for this in the schedule. If the decision is negative, the exam result remains unchanged.

Appeal in case of disagreement with the points received

This type of appeal must be filed within two working days from the date of announcement of the results of the exam in the subject. As in the previous case, you will need to write two copies of the application, sending one of them to the conflict commission (through the school principal or an employee authorized by him), and keeping the second for yourself. The application must be marked with a note that it is accepted for consideration and drawn up in accordance with the form. You need to require a form with 1-AP encoding.

Note: if the appeal is filed by a person who graduated from school earlier than the current academic year, it must be given to the employee representing the place of your registration for the exam.

The decision to hold an appeal must be made no later than 4 working days after the receipt of such an application by the conflict commission. Each application goes through a registration process, and information regarding the date, time and place of the appeal is communicated to the student (his parents or guardians). If the student is under 18 years of age, legal representatives may come to the appeal without the student. You need to come to the indicated place with a passport and a pass.

The student must be shown a package of his documents and a written conclusion of the commission on the subject. At this stage, you need to be especially careful: the student will have to sign that the scanned or written work, audio files with answers and minutes of the oral part of the exam are yours. Members of the Appeal Panel must be clear about why certain scores were awarded. The procedure takes no more than 20 minutes per student. As a result of this event, the commission may decide:

• reject the student's requirements and keep the assigned points if no technical or other errors were found in the assessment process;
• satisfy the appeal and change the points if errors were found in the technical part or the scoring procedure. However, it is worth remembering that points can be revised in both directions (increased or reduced).

How to behave on appeal?

Students who have previously experienced the appeal process have provided some useful tips and advice for the 2017/2018 graduates. So - how to increase your chances of a favorable outcome of the procedure?

• Go to your appeal with your mom, dad, or another adult who can represent you. Yesterday's schoolboy, most likely, will be confused in the face of the conflict commission. In addition, he may be given an answer devoid of specifics. Mom, dad or another close person will help you feel much more confident, and their opinion and arguments can play a decisive role in the dispute.
• Insist that the work be rechecked in your presence. Quite often, the graduate is told that the work has already been rechecked, and the commission decided to leave the result unchanged. Remember that this state of affairs grossly violates your rights - an absentee appeal is possible only if the student and his representatives simply did not appear at the procedure. The final decision on the work must be made in the presence of the appellant, and the members of the commission must explain each deducted point.
• Do not leave the venue of the appeal until a full explanation of the work and decision of the commission has been given. All low scores must meet the criteria put forward for evaluating the work, so do not accept as an answer the general wording that the scores for the solved CMM are already high enough. Until you are satisfied with the explanation for each deducted point, do not sign the appeal documents.
• Don't give up halfway. If you have already decided to appeal, then, in fact, there is nothing to lose. If they try to intimidate you, the commission does not give clear answers, and the procedure is far from objectivity, you can file a second (federal) appeal. With this procedure, the work is sent for re-checking, and the new commission does not know how many points you were awarded last time. Of course, this is not a clear chance of success, but you will know for sure that you did your best.
• Do not be afraid of this procedure. A significant part of the students who are not satisfied with their results are simply afraid to go to the appeal so as not to lose extra points. Of course, if a member of the commission finds additional errors during the check, the points may be revised downward. However, if you look at the statistics of appeals, you can see the following figures: in 2015 alone, the commission of the Tomsk region made a positive decision on 25% of all appeals. The same percentage of positive outcomes was registered in the Tyumen region - out of 900 appellants, only eight had their points lowered. The commission, which met in the Khabarovsk Territory, raised the marks of a third of the guys who applied, and the rest of the works remained at their points.
• Be calm and confident. Take this procedure as an opportunity to defend your position, and not as a showdown on raised voices. If you are rude, yelling, or throwing accusations and threats, you are unlikely to be met.

What should be done before the day of the appeal?

It is quite clear that the passage of such an exciting procedure as an appeal will require a certain moral and psychological preparation. Here are a few helpful tips to help you:

• Refresh your work. After the announcement of the scores, the work of schoolchildren is displayed in their personal accounts. Carefully read the scoring criteria to understand how objective you think the commission's decision on each item is;
• approach the subject teacher or tutor with whom you were preparing for the exam - they will help you sort out the ambiguous points and give recommendations on how to behave and explain your opinion. In some cases, teachers can prove to you that there is no mistake, so you should not waste time and nerves on appeal procedures;
• for each point with which you disagree, formulate an exact question to the commission in advance so that the conversation is substantive, and you can explain why you used this or that argument, quote, analogy or characterization. Argumentation supported by concrete facts looks more weighty.

In case of disagreement with the points set for the exam, the annulment of the assessment results, the illegal removal of the child from the exam, the parents - and the student himself - can file an appeal.

Let's consider what is the procedure for appealing scoring results, when and how you can challenge the received document. You will also learn what the practice of the Russian courts is on this issue - and which side the judges take.

In what cases can an appeal be filed for the exam - deadlines for filing an appeal

A student undergoing the Unified State Exam procedure can challenge the decision of the commission, but the deadlines for applying and filing an appeal are different.

We list when and in what cases a student can appeal a decision.

Recall , that the student should have been informed 2 weeks before the exam about how the passing procedure will take place, in what time it will be possible to appeal the decision, in what place.

It will not work in any way to challenge the decision of the commission if the student or parent wants to emphasize the incorrect content of the test tasks, the incorrectness of the child filling out the forms, the student's non-compliance with the requirements set by the members of the commission.

The procedure for appealing the USE in case of violation of the rules for conducting the Unified State Exam - instructions

In order to challenge the decision of the commission, if the child was illegally kicked out of the exam - or the procedure for conducting the Unified State Exam was violated for some other reason, you must follow the instructions:

Step 1. After submitting the forms, going out into the corridor, the student must contact the organizer.

Step 2 Explain that you want to appeal, state the reason.

Step 3 Ask for an application form. If the organizers will stand their ground - to persuade you not to write an appeal, do not listen to them. If you decide that you were illegally kicked out of the exam, then it is better to write an appeal right away. Then it will not be considered.

Step 4 Write a statement. In it, be sure to indicate for what reason the USE procedure was violated. Prepare two copies of the application.

Step 5 Give the organizer one copy of the application and keep the other for yourself, but only ask the teacher to sign it. This will serve as proof of your appeal.

Step 6 Wait for the results of the commission - they will be ready within 2 days. The student and parents may be invited to the meeting of the commission. You should have your passport with you.

Results of the conflict commission can be obtained at the school where the child is studying.

The decision must be written in the documentation, as well as the date and time of the retake of the exam.

How to challenge the results of the exam in case of disagreement with the points obtained for the exam - instructions

To challenge the points already received, parents, or the student himself, must follow the following instructions:

Step 1. Contact the school where you are studying.

Step 2 Ask for an appeal form.

Step 3 Write a statement. It must be in the name of the director.

Step 4 Ask to sign the document. One option the parent or student must keep for themselves in order to have proof of their conversion. The other one should be given to the director.

Step 5 Wait for the committee's decision. The director must submit the application-appeal to the conflict commission. The date of the event can be communicated to the student if his presence is required.

As a rule, the application is considered quickly - within 1 week. After receiving the documentation, the student will either be assigned a retake day, or will increase / decrease the score results, or retain the existing scores.

The procedure for considering an appeal to the exam and terms

The procedure for considering applications for appealing the results of the exam is as follows:

1. The organizers must accept the student's appeal.
2. The application is submitted to the conflict commission, which does not include members of the subject commission.
3. If necessary, the participants of the conflict committee send a request to the RCOI of a certain object of the Russian Federation to provide information about the student passing the exam. Videos, audio recordings, copies of protocols and other paper documentation may be submitted for consideration.
4. The conflict commission must check how the student's examination work was assessed, according to all the requirements, and make a decision.

IMPORTANT: Parents or students may be invited to the meeting. They may be provided with an answer sheet filled out by the graduate to confirm that it was the applicant who did the work. Also, members of the subject committee may be invited to the meeting to establish the correctness of the assessment of the student.

The student will be able to receive the decision of the commission within 4 days at the school where he is studying.

Judicial practice of appealing the results of the exam - how and when can you file a lawsuit?

After contacting the conflict commission, if the decision is not satisfactory, the student or his legal representatives can file a claim with the court.

Terms for applying not defined by law.

Of course, the sooner the claim is filed, the better. The child will have time to retake the exam this year.

In practice, judges do not always take the side of the students.

Here are a few examples where the court agreed with the decision of the conflict commission:

Example 1 Petrov was kicked out of the exam due to cheating. Violations have been proven.

Example 2 Sokolova used a wrist watch with the function of receiving and transmitting data.

Example 3 Ivanov's cheat sheet fell out, but he was not caught cheating. Later, a video was sent, which showed how Ivanov was cheating.

And here are examples when parents and a graduate achieved recognition of their innocence:

Example 1 Sidorov was next to someone else's phone - he was lying on the floor when the student went to the toilet. The organizer demanded to pick up his phone, but Sidorov refused - he said that it was not his device. The organizer expelled the graduate from the exam - thus, he was wrong.

Students have the right to file an application-appeal to review the points received and retake it to the conflict commission or to the court. In 2018, the application form does not change - the appeal forms are provided for by the current legislation of the Russian Federation.

We will consider what statements a student or his legal representative can issue, and also determine how a lawsuit is drawn up in court.

Appeal form for the exam and a sample of filling out the document

Depending on the circumstances of the appeal, the appeal forms may be different.

We list what documents can be issued.

Sample appeal form for disagreement with the USE scores

A ready-made appeal form for disagreement with the USE scores can be free

An example of a completed application-appeal about disagreement with the points received

Appeal form for violation of the established procedure for conducting the exam

A ready-made appeal form for violation of the established procedure for conducting the exam can be free

In order for you to write the application correctly, follow these rules:

1. The item code should be written in numbers. You will learn it when you take the exam.
2. Enter the place of the exam, the date in the indicated fields provided for this.
3. If it is necessary to indicate the number of the audience where the Unified State Exam was taken, the point of holding, then indicate. This applies to the application for violation of the order of the exam.
4. Information about the USE participant must be indicated such as in the passport. Any altered or misspelled letter will be considered an error.
5. Passport details indicate in the appropriate boxes. Mandatory - series and number, other information can be omitted.
6. This is followed by your appeal, in which you must state the essence of the requirements and requests. For example, in the first application-appeal, it will be written that you are asking the commission to review the points given, as they are processed incorrectly. And in the second appeal, you should specify the circumstances that occurred, for what reason the points were canceled (possibly due to illegal removal from the exam), and also in this part you should ask for a retake of the subject.
7. If there is a choice of how the application will be considered, then it is worth putting a cross or a tick in front of the appropriate option. In a score disagreement appeal, there is such a choice. The student may choose to have the application reviewed in his presence or in the presence of his legal representative, or without him at all. But in another form there is no choice, since the appeal will definitely be considered in the presence of the student or his parents.
8. You can also leave a phone number so that you are aware of the progress of the application.
9. The student must put his signature when he submits the document.

In confirmation of the acceptance of the appeal, the student is given notification. The organizer must put on it the exact time when he accepted the application, and his initials, signature.

Statement of claim in court when appealing the results of the exam - rules for writing a document and examples

Pupils and their parents/legal representatives may challenge the decision of the conflict committee through the courts. To do this, you need to file an administrative claim.

The application is drawn up in accordance with Article 125 of the CAS RF and in accordance with the following rules:

1. The document must be submitted in writing.
2. Text content should be legible and understandable.
3. The application must include a heading. It contains the name of the body to which the application is submitted, information about the plaintiff and the defendant. As a rule, the student himself, his parents, representatives, teacher, class teacher, director of the educational institution can act as a plaintiff. In as a defendant in court will be a representative of the conflict commission, the organizers.
4. Write down all contact information in the "header" of the document. It can be not only a phone number, but also the name of an email, fax.
5. In the main part of the claim, indicate what rights and interests were violated, for what reason you are going to court.
6. Be sure to tell us that you appealed to the conflict commission with an appeal and tried to resolve the problem out of court.
7. The content requirements must be substantiated. Refer to legal acts, attach evidence, indicate witnesses.
8. At the end of the claim, you can draw up a list of documents that you attach to the application.
9. Put a signature. If the applicant is a student, then he must put his signature. If its representatives file a claim, they sign it.
10. The date must be set when you submit the document to the court, not earlier, the document will not be accepted “backdating”.